Choosing between a dog harness and a collar isn't just a fashion decision, it directly affects your dog's comfort and safety. In the Netherlands, where dogs often accompany their family members on bicycle rides, through crowded city centers like Amsterdam or Utrecht, gear that prevents injuries and gives you control is vital. Here's why a harness is generally better than a collar and why modern Y-shaped harnesses, especially those with GPS step tracking, are ideal for dogs.
How harnesses protect your dog
A well-fitting harness distributes pressure across the chest and shoulders instead of focusing it on the neck. The Dutch pet-sitting platform Petbnb explains that a harness spreads pressure across the dog's chest and shoulders rather than the neck and throat. This reduces the risk of tracheal collapse, nerve damage or thyroid injury when your dog pulls or suddenly lunges during a busy sidewalk stroll. The American Kennel Club notes that harnesses are popular because they prevent throat damage and stop the leash from getting tangled under the dog's legs. Front-clip harnesses also discourage pulling because they apply gentle pressure on the chest instead of the neck.
Because the pressure is spread over a larger area, harnesses are especially recommended for puppies, small breeds and brachycephalic dogs (Pugs, French Bulldogs) that have delicate airways. The Federation of Veterinarians of Europe supports using harnesses for dogs with respiratory or neck problems. In the Netherlands, many dogs travel by bike; a harness reduces the chance of injury during sudden stops or when negotiating narrow cycle paths.
Benefits over collars
Dutch dog-care experts at Petbnb list several advantages of harnesses:
- Less pressure on the neck and throat
- More control in crowded situations
- Ideal for active dogs and dog sports
Note: Collars remain useful for attaching an ID tag or quick trips around the block. However, they concentrate force on a small area, so a dog that pulls can injure its neck or even slip out. Petbnb warns that collars put pressure on the neck and trachea and are not suitable for intensive training or sports. AKC also notes that collars may allow some dogs to wiggle out and are less comfortable for dogs that tug.
Why a Y-shaped harness is the best choice
Not all harnesses are created equal. Y-shaped harnesses have two loops, one around the neck and one around the chest, that meet at the chest bone, forming a "Y". This design avoids crossing over the shoulders and allows freedom of movement. A recent article on Canine Culture explains that the Y-shape distributes pressure evenly across the dog's chest and shoulders, preventing choking and strain. The front clip on a Y-shaped harness helps redirect a pulling dog without causing discomfort, making walks through busy streets or bike paths more relaxed.
Comfort and ergonomic design are other advantages. Y-shaped harnesses are padded and contoured to prevent chafing. They support natural posture, reducing the risk of long term neck or spine problems. The design also allows for full shoulder movement, which is important for dog sports and off-leash running.
Fitting your harness
A poorly fitting harness can rub or restrict movement. Petbnb suggests measuring both the chest and neck circumference and ensuring the shoulders remain free. Choose soft but sturdy materials and gradually accustom your dog to wearing the harness with short, positive sessions. If in doubt, consult a veterinarian or a qualified hondencoach for help.
Conclusion
For Dutch dog owners, a harness, especially a Y-shaped smart harness with GPS and step tracking, provides greater comfort, safety and control than a collar. It distributes pressure across the chest instead of the neck, offers better control in crowded places, and supports active lifestyles and sports. Y-shaped designs maximise freedom of movement while preventing injuries. By choosing the right ergonomic dog harness and ensuring a proper fit, you'll safeguard your dog's wellbeing on every adventure, whether strolling along the countryside, a dog park, in the city, or exploring off-leash forests.